Join jaguars.com senior editor Vic Ketchman as he tackles the fans' tough questions.
Dave from Springfield, MA
How close are the Jags to signing Harvey and Groves? Is signing as quickly as possible the best situation for the player and team?
Vic: Ask yourself this: Is it good to put a lot of money into the hands of a young man who has nothing to do for the next few weeks but spend that money? Is there any chance that it would be for his own good that he remain a poor college kid for at least another couple of weeks?
Max from Jacksonville
Take us on a trip down memory lane. What was your impression of the city of Jacksonville before you moved here? What were your thoughts at the time on the city being awarded an expansion team?
Vic: The first time I saw it, which was on a cloudless winter day, I loved it. I won’t lie and tell you I wasn’t stunned at how small the downtown was, but I loved what I saw and everyone was telling me that Jacksonville was passionate about football and that the town’s passion for the game would overcome what it lacked in resources. Right from the beginning, I knew Jacksonville would have to over-achieve to be competitive in the NFL arena, but all expectations were that the town and its football fans would, in fact, over-achieve.
Michael from Orange Park, FL
Who do you think will be the first player from the Jags that makes it into the Hall of Fame? Or has such a player not come along yet?
Vic: Fred Taylor is the Jaguars’ best candidate.
Scott from Aurora, IL
What is the difference between a hard cap and the current cap?
Vic: In a hard-cap system, everything that is spent in the year must be on that year’s cap. In a hard-cap system, signing bonus would not be amortized evenly over the life of the contract. Signing bonus would be treated as roster bonus, which is to say that what’s paid in the year stays in the year. The current system is a soft-cap concept that allows for money to be pushed out onto future caps. In many cases, that money is pushed onto caps of years for which the team has no intent of retaining the player. Given that kind of abuse, it’s hard to imagine that back in 1993 the owners who devised and supported the current cap system actually believed it would restrict spending. They were obviously counting on leaguethink, and that mentality was already in the process of eroding.
Will from Jacksonville
Who is the most underrated team in the league?
Vic: I would be tempted to say Houston or Buffalo, but is there anything in the NFL that’s underrated?
John from Jacksonville
As a season ticket holder, I have noticed that almost all games are well attended, yet, we get a black eye from the media because we have had some blackouts. Where do the Jaguars rank in total attendance vs. the rest of the league?
Vic: I don’t know and I don’t care because that’s a meaningless statistic. All it shows is which teams have the largest seating capacities. You don’t judge a team’s success at the box office by its total attendance, you judge its success by the price of its tickets, the size of its waiting list and, in some cases, by the price of its PSLs.
Trent from Tallahassee, FL
If you say an implemented hard cap would have fixed many of the salary cap issues, why was it turned down?
Vic: A hard-cap system would’ve caused immediate hardship for a few of the top teams in the league at that time. It would’ve caused those teams to immediately lose prominent players, effectively ending their runs. To get an agreement on the salary cap concept, a compromise to a soft-cap system was made. It was a mistake. The players union would’ve accepted a hard cap back then. They won’t now.
Tyler from Cold Spring, MN
What do you think of the Sonics moving to Oklahoma City?
Vic: It’s professional sports; it’s about the money. In the old days, the money wasn’t that big and teams could ride out their lean years. They could hang in there longer as they developed their fan base. These days, the money is so big that losses can quickly multiply and put a team in an unrecoverable financial position. I don’t know the specifics of the Sonics’ situation, but I’m inclined to believe it’s financially motivated.
Georges from Jacksonville
If the average NFL free agent is offered decent money to play for a team that went 13-3 the year before, or great money to go to a team that was 3-13 the year before, which one do you think he would take?
Vic: He’d take the 3-13 team.
Fred from Brunswick, GA
Does it boggle your mind to get e-mails from people who obviously read your column with regularity and trash your opinions and write about how bad it is and continue to be loyal readers?
Vic: No, it doesn’t boggle my mind. It’s all part of the we-must-protect-this-house mentality. Anger and the expression of it gives today’s fans a rush of power and esteem.
Nick from Hanover, NH
Is it required that some number (seven?) of players be on the line of scrimmage? Could, for example, all linemen, except, I guess, the center, be lined up a yard or so in the backfield together?
Vic: Seven or more players must be on the line of scrimmage or a penalty will result.
Chad from Bowling Green, KY
Pete Prisco of CBSsportsline.com recently included Troy Williamson and Justin Durant in his top 30 list of players to have breakout years. Durant was fourth on the list, making it sound like he is poised for a big year. What do you think?
Vic: Those are good choices, but I would caution that Durant would seem to be in a competition for the strong side linebacker job and that would represent a new position for him. I have no doubt that he has all of the coverage skills necessary to succeed, but it’s not as though he’s done a lot of it in his years at Hampton and his one year with the Jaguars. I wouldn’t set the bar too high for Durant in just his second year; be reasonable. As for Williamson, yeah, based on what I saw in the spring, he could be headed for a breakout year, but I would also caution that OTAs are not real football. Let’s be reasonable on both counts.
Chris from Mansfield, TX
I'm with Jason. I have put in several good questions about the Jags but somehow I get passed up for Tiger questions or ridiculous questions about who the Jags can least afford to lose.
Vic: Just think about all the people who’ve had their good questions ignored so I could run a question from somebody whining about not having his questions used.
Michael from Fruit Cove, FL
I know you're not a tennis fan, but what happened at Wimbledon this year was amazing. Federer and Nadal have one of the greatest rivalries in sports today and we're lucky to be able to see it.
Vic: I had just come off the golf course as the match was winding down. We sat at a table near a TV and I was seated with my back to the television. Never once as we enjoyed our cold, post-round refreshments was I even tempted to turn around and look at the TV. I think I heard a couple of grunts, though.
Joe from Jacksonville
I think David Garrard will bring a new swagger that will be contagious throughout the locker room. Even before the contract, Garrard displayed supreme confidence in himself and the team. His style in postgame attire lets everyone know the Jags are for real and in the limelight. And finally, David Garrard has become an extension of Jack Del Rio and the physical attitude he has instilled in his team. It’s the attitude that says, “This is going to be the longest day of your life. We're going to push you around, beat you up and punish you for four quarters.” I believe the team will feel the vibe all the way through the playoffs.
Vic: Oh, my, you’re giving me chills. What happens if the other guy is bigger, stronger and faster? Who has the swagger then?
Bob from Somerset, PA
The Colts are inside the heads of Jags fans. My concern is, can this transfer to the players? Are the Colts inside the players’ heads already?
Vic: Fans deal with the head. Players deal with the body. I can tell you with absolute certainty that the number one thought on every player’s mind is the satisfactory execution of his role. If he does his job on Sunday, he’s happy. Why shouldn’t he be? What else can he do but his job?
Dan from Jacksonville
Could you explain the Oklahoma drill?
Vic: Two tackling dummies or pylons five yards apart, one blocker, one defender, one running back, one ball. It’s real football for real men.
Henry from Jacksonville
What are the rules regarding practice squad players moving to other teams' practice squads?
Vic: Any team signing a player off another team’s practice squad must immediately place that player on the signing team’s active roster. If a player on one team’s practice squad is waived by that team, however, he may be signed by another team to its practice squad.
Jami from Arlington, VA
I noticed the pitch to sell tickets when I logged on. Where does the team stand on remaining non-premium and premium seats left to be sold?
Vic: It’s July and non-premium and premium-seat tickets are still for sale. What else is there to say? I’m not gonna play the numbers game because it’s getting real old. It’s July and tickets are for sale. What’s that tell you?