To determine the Top 25, we asked eight local media members – Gene Frenette of the Florida Times-Union, Dan Hicken of First Coast News, San Kouvaris of WJXT-4, Jeff Lageman of Jaguars television and radio, John Oehser of jaguars.com, Pete Prisco of CBSSports.com, Brian Sexton of Jaguars radio and television and Vito Stellino of the Florida Times-Union – to vote on their Top 50 Jaguars.
From that, we determined the Top 25 Jaguars.
The list, and particularly the top players on the list, will surely generate a lot of discussion. To add to that, here's the Top 10 of each panelist:
| Gene Frenette | Dan Hicken | Sam Kouvaris | Jeff Lageman | John Oehser | Pete Prisco | Brian Sexton | Vito Stellino | |
| @GeneFrenette | @danhicken | @samkouvaris | @JeffLageman | @JohnOehser | @PriscoCBS | @jagsvoice | @vitostellino | |
| 1 | T. Boselli | T. Boselli | F. Taylor | F. Taylor | T. Boselli | T. Boselli | F. Taylor | T. Boselli |
| 2 | F. Taylor | F. Taylor | T. Boselli | T. Boselli | F. Taylor | F. Taylor | T. Boselli | F. Taylor |
| 3 | J. Smith | J. Smith | M. Brunell | J. Smith | J. Smith | J. Smith | J. Smith | J. Smith |
| 4 | M. Brunell | Jones-Drew | Jones-Drew | R. Mathis | Jones-Drew | Jones-Drew | Jones-Drew | T. Brackens |
| 5 | Jones-Drew | M. Brunell | J. Smith | Jones-Drew | T. Brackens | K. McCardell | T. Brackens | Jones-Drew |
| 6 | T. Brackens | T. Brackens | R. Mathis | K. McCardell | M. Brunell | M. Brunell | M. Brunell | M. Brunell |
| 7 | K. McCardell | R. Mathis | T. Brackens | D. Smith | K. McCardell | R. Mathis | R. Mathis | M. Stroud |
| 8 | M. Stroud | M. Stroud | M. Stroud | M. Brunell | R. Mathis | T. Brackens | D. Smith | J. Henderson |
| 9 | R. Mathis | K. McCardell | Kyle Brady | T. Brackens | M. Stroud | D. Smith | K. McCardell | L. Searcy |
| 10 | L. Searcy | D. Smith | J. Henderson | B. Meester | J. Henderson | M. Stroud | B. Meester | K. McCardell |
