JACKSONVILLE – Each week during the 2026 season, Jaguars "experts" – Frank Frangie, Brent Martineau, John Oehser, Brian Sexton, Mark Duffner, Austen Lane, John Shipley and Kainani Stevens – will analyze the week's Jaguars matchup.
Up this week:
Frank Frangie, Radio Voice of the Jaguars
- The Jaguars will win if: They don't get caught up in the big moment of the Big Apple and just play as they have been playing. Lawrence is playing at an All-Pro level and the Jaguars' passing game is elite. They must continue to find balance with the running game. The Jaguars' run defense should become even better — and overall defense as well — with Davis and Bates in the lineup. The Jaguars must just keep doing what they have been doing.
- The Giants will win if: They get Lawrence off his spot AND stuff the run, which few teams have been able to do against the Jaguars. They must protect McCarthy and keep the game close well into the second half. The longer it is close, the more confidence they will gain.
- As Frangie sees it: The Jags have the better team and should win. I write that every week, but it is what I believe. The Giants have a terrific coach in Harbaugh and have had a good first half of the season. But they don't have a victory against a team with a winning record and if the Jags take care of business, they will win.
Brent Martineau, Action Sports Jax Sports Director
- The Jaguars will win if: They run for more yards than the Giants. Late November football starts to feel different, and the physicality really shows up. The Jaguars are scoring a bunch, but don't get enough credit for their physical brand of football. The Giants will bring that playstyle, too, and the Jaguars will have to win the running game to win.
- The Giants will win if: Tight end Isaiah Likely and wide receiver Malik Nabers have good days. Likely is dangerous with 55 receptions and seven touchdowns so far this season. Nabers has 58 receptions and almost 700 yards. If the Jaguars contain those two pass catchers, the Giants will have a tough time keeping up on the scoreboard.
- As Martineau sees it: This is going to be a good one, folks. The Jaguars have made things look easy, but that won't be the case against the Giants. I think this is a fourth-quarter game, and the Jaguars will have to make a couple of big plays to close it out on the road. I think they will. Jaguars win, 27-20.
John Oehser, jaguars.com senior writer
- The Jaguars will win if: They out-physical the Giants and handle the blitz. Both teams want to be physical, so whichever team wins that will have an advantage. The Giants' defense is built on the blitz. If the Jaguars get the Giants blocked, the Giants will have difficulty handling the Jaguars' versatile group of receivers and tight ends.
- The Giants will win if: They outrun the Jaguars and hit multiple explosive plays. The Jaguars on paper are the more explosive offense. If the Giants can beat the Jaguars' top-rated run defense, and if McCarthy can beat the Jaguars' secondary for a big play or two, the Jaguars will have a tough time playing to their style.
- As Oehser sees it: This game will be about the line of scrimmage. I expect the Jaguars will handle the Giants' physicality and give Trevor Lawrence just enough time just often enough to hit enough explosive plays to earn a tight victory.
Brian Sexton, jaguars.com senior correspondent
- The Jaguars will win if: They score touchdowns instead of field goals. The offense has scored 33 and 40 in back-to-back victories but settled for eight field goals in those games. It's no stretch to say they should have scored 50 in each of the last two games and Head Coach Liam Coen certainly thinks so. The running game needs to keep third downs manageable for quarterback Trevor Lawrence and Co., so they can convert all those yards into points.
- The Giants will win if: They control the line of scrimmage. The Giants are mid-league at 118 yards per game rushing and bottom-third at 3.91 yards per rushing attempt this season. Running back Cam Skattebo has big runs but is averaging just 4.3 yards per carry. However, he has a knack for important runs in key moments that keep drives alive. The Giants are No. 1 in the NFL in time of possession, which is how they stay in games. If Skattebo can keep Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy ahead of the chains, the Giants can win.
- As Sexton sees it: The Jaguars are the better team, and they're fortified by the additions of defensive tackle Jordan Davis and safety Jessie Bates III this week. I expect them to keep Skattebo from running wild, which should set up the secondary to make some plays against McCarthy, who has more career interceptions than touchdowns. The Jaguars win this one, probably in the fourth quarter.

Join us at The 'Bank
Secure tickets today for our Salute to Service game against the Titans on November 29.
Mark Duffner, longtime NFL assistant coach and Jaguars analyst
- The Jaguars will win if: The offense continues to score and protect Lawrence. The Giants' defense is second in the NFL in blitz rate and they also play one of the highest percentages of man coverage. The Jaguars must make them pay by continuing the "explosive" play attack shown in the first half against Tennessee last week.
- The Giants will win if: They make explosive plays offensively and affect Lawrence with their blitz package. The Jaguars must contain McCarthy – and cover Nabers and Likely – and swarm and gang tackle Skattebo.
- As Duffner sees it: The Jaguars will start fast, and handle the crowd noise and weather. The Giants haven't won a game this season when trailing in the fourth quarter, so getting the lead will be key for the Jaguars. The Jaguars need good technique, execution and focus to win.
Austen Lane, former NFL defensive end and Jaguars analyst
- The Jaguars will win if: They can execute one of the biggest clichés in football: run the ball and stop the run. The Giants rank among the league leaders in time of possession, largely because of their ability to establish the ground game. If Jacksonville can run effectively against a Giants defense surrendering 4.5 yards per carry, while shutting down Skattebo on the other side, the rest should take care of itself.
- The Giants will win if: They find creative ways to get Nabers involved and Likely open. Jacksonville has shown a vulnerability to explosive plays, particularly against No. 1 receivers and vertical threats. Nabers checks both boxes. Even with the addition of Bates, the Jaguars still must prove they can consistently eliminate big plays through the air. Defensively, despite ranking near the bottom of the league in pressure rate, the Giants are an aggressive blitzing team. If they can disguise their pressures and confuse new starting center Jonah Monheim, they could create problems for Lawrence.
- How Lane sees it: There's a growing narrative that the Jaguars' résumé isn't as impressive as their record suggests. Here's what matters: The Jaguars are the only NFL team ranked in the top five in both scoring offense and scoring defense. Spin it however you want. That's impressive. Give me the more complete team to get it done on the road. Jaguars 31, Giants 20.
John Shipley, Jaguars correspondent
- The Jaguars will win if: They force McCarthy into the mistakes that have followed him in his NFL career thus far. He can look like a franchise quarterback one play and toss a ball directly to the defense on the next, making the kind of inconsistent mistakes that follow most young quarterbacks. If the Jaguars use their scheme and force him into mistakes, as they have done often to many quarterbacks the past two seasons, they will give themselves more and more opportunities to attack the Giants' defense.
- The Giants will win if: They get after Lawrence. The Giants have numerous big-name draft picks across their defensive front with Abdul Carter, Kayvon Thibodeaux and Arvell Reese – and the Jaguars must account for them. The Jaguars have done a good job keeping Lawrence clean when it matters most, but they will face few teams with the young, explosive pieces on the Giants' defense. If the Jaguars can't protect Lawrence, it could be tough for the Jaguars' high-powered passing game.
- As Shipley sees it: The Jaguars are the more mature and experienced team, and they have the quarterback advantage. The Giants are a hard-nosed team under Head Coach John Harbaugh that should fight the Jaguars for four quarters, but Lawrence should be expected to outduel McCarthy when it counts. Jaguars win this one, 27-20.
Kainani Stevens, Jaguars team reporter
- The Jaguars will win if: They limit explosives on defense and find a rhythm with the run game. Nabers has big-play ability and slowing him is crucial, but wide receiver/cornerback Travis Hunter is more than up to the task. The Jags have been trying to get the run game going but that may be difficult with the moving parts due to injuries. Jacksonville just needs to do enough to stay balanced on offense and they should be able to find success.
- The Giants will win if: They win in the trenches. While Jonah Monheim is a capable center, this will be his third career start in the NFL. The Giants' pass rush must get after Lawrence and keep the Jacksonville offense off the field. Likewise, the Giants' offensive line must hold off the Jaguars' defensive line.
- As Stevens sees it: This will be the most physical matchup the Jaguars have encountered in weeks, and I think the score will reflect that. The Jaguars will sneak away with a hard-fought victory. Jaguars, 21-17.















